Porco Rosso likeliness?

Date : August 15, 2009

Category : Default / Other

Question :


Anyone who watches Porco Rosso will notice the similarities with Talespin. Although, the film Porco Rosso was released 2 years later than the first airing of Talespin...

So the question is : is it just a coincidence?


Best answer :


I'd always felt that Hayao was lookin' at our stuff (I remember coming up with the inlet to the island, city on the inside drawing... and I can't draw); God knows we were looking at his. I think the contrail/heaven scene is one of the great moments in movies (not just animation) - it ranks with Lawrence of Arabia blowing out the match, cut to sunrise moment in my opinion. One of the things that Miyazaki can do (that we could only nod to) was character subtlety and plot sophistication. Plunder & Lightning was fine and dandy, but a middle-aged pig that feels guilt for living through the war when his companions did not... that's just wonder.

My two cents,

Mark Zaslove

This question has been solved.





Report this question Report this question

12798 visits



Last comments

Marcus
Marcus
September 14, 2012
Know your stuff morons!

Miyazaki DREW a manga novel that will become Porco Rosso, before MARCH 1989.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hik%C5%8Dtei_Jidai

You can easily find the nicely drawn manga on the web.

So if someone had copied material, it would be Disney.
Anyway in this case I think that at the time there was some kind of common culture out of stuff from the 60's about planes and pirates. So the origins must be from there.

Microsoft made a game at the time that was very close to this universe too :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimson_Skies_%28video_game%29

March 21, 2010
Chile
:P when I saw the movie porco rosso, I thought ... "Mr. Miyazaki've seen Talespin? , It is very suspicious.
I love his movies too.;)

August 20, 2009
Webmaster France Male
AS leader
Ok thanks :)
Well it was a great inspiration, for sure. But in the end, I think you made a very unique series / universe : and it's probably the most important.

August 17, 2009
Mark's right. We all owe a huge debt to Miyazaki. In fact, the day that Art Vitello was brought in to direct Gummi Bears, exec Michael Webster basically shoved us at one another and said, "Here, get to know each other - you'll be working together for the next year." Art had been in animation for years, I had never done a single show. So Art said, "I want you to watch two movies before we even talk. Then you'll know what is possible." He showed me Nausicaa and La Puta... in Japanese! I didn't have a clue what was going on, but I couldn't get over the aerial scenes! I was an instant convert.

Then when I hired Mark a year or two later, I did the same thing - showed him Miyazaki. He was blown away, as well. Obviously it influenced us when it came time to create Tale Spin.

I will say, however, that I think Mr. Miyazaki saw Tale Spin at some point, cuz the likenesses are striking. The narrow gorge entrance to an inland bay. A sea plane. A fat mammal main character. Air pirates. Hmmmmm........ Maybe that was his way of honoring us (or more likely payback for ripping off his great aerial stuff!) :)
JM

August 17, 2009
I'd always felt that Hayao was lookin' at our stuff (I remember coming up with the inlet to the island, city on the inside drawing... and I can't draw); God knows we were looking at his. I think the contrail/heaven scene is one of the great moments in movies (not just animation) - it ranks with Lawrence of Arabia blowing out the match, cut to sunrise moment in my opinion. One of the things that Miyazaki can do (that we could only nod to) was character subtlety and plot sophistication. Plunder & Lightning was fine and dandy, but a middle-aged pig that feels guilt for living through the war when his companions did not... that's just wonder.

My two cents,

Mark Zaslove

August 16, 2009
Webmaster France Male
AS leader
Well I have seen it, and even though I usually like Miyazaki's films, I almost found it boring - considering it's veeeeery slow.
I think that Plunder & lightning with the same animation quality / budget as Porco Rosso would have beaten it all the way (and probably would be one of the most famous Disney films, IF it would have been released in theaters)

But I guess it's better to make your own opinion :)

August 16, 2009
Usa Female
not sure.. but I've been wanting to see the film myself for a while :)..

at least the film doesn't have a humanoid bear in it :)




Not connected : To be able to post a message site, you must be connected.

Register on the site!

TaleSpin reads and more


Site activity




Quick menu

Close
Fanart
Fanart
Images
Images
Fanfic
Fanfic
Musics
Musics
Videos
Videos
Gamebooks
Gamebooks
Projects
Projects
Contests
Contests
Characters
Characters
Ask Questions
Ask Questions
Articles
Articles
Reviews
Reviews
Treasure Planet
Treasure Planet
Regular Show
Regular Show
My Neighbor Totoro
My Neighbor Totoro
We're Back! A Dinosaur's Story
We're Back! A Dinosaur's Story
The Land Before Time
The Land Before Time
Avatar
Avatar
Steven Universe
Steven Universe
Bluey
Bluey
Scooby-Doo
Scooby-Doo
Balto
Balto
The Lion King
The Lion King
TaleSpin
TaleSpin
Spirit
Spirit
All Dogs Go To Heaven
All Dogs Go To Heaven
Princess & The Frog
Princess & The Frog
Brother Bear
Brother Bear
The Fox and the Hound
The Fox and the Hound
The Aristocats
The Aristocats
Oliver & Company
Oliver & Company
Lady & The Tramp
Lady & The Tramp
Robin Hood
Robin Hood
Cats Don't Dance
Cats Don't Dance
Gummi Bears
Gummi Bears
Bambi
Bambi
Mulan
Mulan
Anastasia
Anastasia
Rio
Rio
Jungle Book
Jungle Book
How To Train Your Dragon
How To Train Your Dragon
101 Dalmatians
101 Dalmatians
Tangled
Tangled
Watership Down
Watership Down
Frozen
Frozen
My Little Pony
My Little Pony
The Secret of Nimh
The Secret of Nimh
Gravity Falls
Gravity Falls
Ice Age
Ice Age
Ginga
Ginga
Despicable Me
Despicable Me
Bolt
Bolt
Zootopia
Zootopia
Over the Hedge
Over the Hedge
Beauty & The Beast
Beauty & The Beast

All sites and forums in the archive

Français   English

RSS      Bookmark the site      Privacy policy      1 visitor connected

Generated in 0.233 seconds