why

Date : September 06, 2010

Category : Film questions

Question :


why did the calvary attack the indain village? i know they were in a war but i still want to know why.


This question has been solved.





Report this question Report this question

461 visits



Last comments

Guest
Guest
September 09, 2010
I don't think it was necessarily that they wanted the Lakota's land, Sure the "White Man" took land without asking, but they also bought some of it and traded goods for it as well.

They were in a war, when people are at war they fight against each other, (and trash their homes/steal goods exec) The Lakota (which is a branch of the Sioux tribe) Did the same thing to the American settlements. (because it was a war and the Natives felt the Americans were intruding on their homeland.)

In the movie it DOES imply that the Railroad workers asked the Army to drive off the Lakota because they were too close to their path for the railroad (or moving in that direction)

Soldier: "Incoming patrol reports hostiles (Lakota) headed North..."

The Colonel: "Ah..."

Soldier "The Railroad has expressed concern... Sir. They've requested additional patrols."

Check near the end of this vid (start around 7:47)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2mppbi9QX4

War is ugly, plain and simple. But neither sides were innocent when it came to fighting against one another.

September 09, 2010
Canada
they weanted the land

Guest
Guest
September 06, 2010
The movie Creators stated in the Commentary that the Colonel only met Spirit out of coincidence every single time their paths crossed he was never out to get Spirit but chased him when they came into contact.

Also, in the Scene before the Colonel rides Spirit he is getting a report that the railroad workers are worried about the Lakota being so close to the Railroad (for the reasons Kirada pointed out) and so that would be a reason to attack and drive them off.

September 06, 2010
Site Builder (Content), Site Builder (Gr... Usa Female
The Valkyrie
It was done quite the norm "back then": Indian villages were pillaged often. I doubt it was JUST because a Lakota stole a horse that would, truthfully, cause more damage than good. Soldiers were under the impression that Native American Indians were ruthless killers -- and the warriors of tribes would become so to protect their people and their land; therefore, soldiers would kill Native Americans without question.

More than likely it was coincidence. I highly doubt that the Colonel knew EXACTLY where the tribe was so he could seek vengeance against Little Creek -- but when he found him and Rain, he was more than happy to take out his "frustrations."



Spirit reads and more


Site activity







Quick menu

Close
Fanart
Fanart
Images
Images
Fanfic
Fanfic
Musics
Musics
Videos
Videos
Gamebooks
Gamebooks
Projects
Projects
Contests
Contests
Characters
Characters
Ask Questions
Ask Questions
Articles
Articles
Reviews
Reviews
Treasure Planet
Treasure Planet
Regular Show
Regular Show
My Neighbor Totoro
My Neighbor Totoro
We're Back! A Dinosaur's Story
We're Back! A Dinosaur's Story
The Land Before Time
The Land Before Time
Avatar
Avatar
Steven Universe
Steven Universe
Bluey
Bluey
Scooby-Doo
Scooby-Doo
Balto
Balto
The Lion King
The Lion King
TaleSpin
TaleSpin
Spirit
Spirit
All Dogs Go To Heaven
All Dogs Go To Heaven
Princess & The Frog
Princess & The Frog
Brother Bear
Brother Bear
The Fox and the Hound
The Fox and the Hound
The Aristocats
The Aristocats
Oliver & Company
Oliver & Company
Lady & The Tramp
Lady & The Tramp
Robin Hood
Robin Hood
Cats Don't Dance
Cats Don't Dance
Gummi Bears
Gummi Bears
Bambi
Bambi
Mulan
Mulan
Anastasia
Anastasia
Rio
Rio
Jungle Book
Jungle Book
How To Train Your Dragon
How To Train Your Dragon
101 Dalmatians
101 Dalmatians
Tangled
Tangled
Watership Down
Watership Down
Frozen
Frozen
My Little Pony
My Little Pony
The Secret of Nimh
The Secret of Nimh
Gravity Falls
Gravity Falls
Ice Age
Ice Age
Ginga
Ginga
Despicable Me
Despicable Me
Bolt
Bolt
Zootopia
Zootopia
Over the Hedge
Over the Hedge
Beauty & The Beast
Beauty & The Beast

All sites and forums in the archive

Français   English

RSS      Bookmark the site      Privacy policy      1 visitor connected

Generated in 0.245 seconds