Animation Source Forums

Hey! This is a question that's aways been bothering me. I think the second is waaaaaaaaay better, but everyone says the 1st is better and the 2nd is crap, what do you think?

The first movie is ALMOST ALWAYS the best, and that's the case here. The second was pretty bad.

The second 1 is really good though, I just like the first better.

The 1st one is so beautiful, but the second one sucks. I give it 1 and 1/2 stars, and I give the 1st one 5 stars. I have 2 reviews on amazon.com. I do however, like Angel. She's the only reason I don't give the 2nd one a 1 star.

I like Angel too. She's not as annoying to me as Scamp XD

Well, I prefer the original movie than the sequel, but I will admit that the sequel did have some things that I liked.

Here's my pros and cons:

Lady and the Tramp

PROs:
- Duh, it's the original Disney classic! It's a tale of love, life, and drama. What else is needed to say?

CONs:
- Uh, there are none IMO.

_____________________________

Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp's Adventure

PROs:
- I like the addition of a couple of the new characters: Angel (Scamp's "puppy-love" interest) and Buster (the leader of the Junkyard Dogs). They helped add some drama and background to certain characters (which I won't name . . . spoilers.)
- Scamp was a well-developed main character, I have to admit. You sort of wanted him to succeed, no matter what happened to him throughout his "adventure" as a wild-and-free dog on the streets.
- The animation and backgrounds . . . . beautiful! I liked the first movie references too (like the spaghetti scene . . . .).

CONs:
- They changed the names of Scamp's sisters!!! Gah. (but at least they suited their "snobby" personalities better . . . originally they were named Ruffles, Fluffy, and Scooter. True fact!)
- Uh, the plot was predictable. With the summary on the back cover, anyone could possibly figure out the ending . . . .
- I think I didn't like the other Junkyard Dogs . . . . they were pointless to me.
- The title sucked. Lady and Tramp didn't do that much in the film, so why were their names in the title (other than the fact that it was the "sequel" of their film)? Why not just call it "Scamp: the Adventure!" or something crappy like that?

That's it. I like the first better, but the second had some things that I thought were good.

- Juuchan17

I like the first one better then the second. Like Juuchan said, Lady and Tramp had only a little dialogue in the second. And that's what always had bothered me...I find Tramp annoying. Angel is probably the only character I liked in the second.

I hate the 1st one, it's so boring and it doesn't make any sense! The songs were HORRIBLE, the animation, terrible with far too many things disappearing or changing colour and the storyline, I can't even explain how much I hated it! Perhaps the only things I like about the film are the love scene, Peg's song: He's a Tramp, the pups at the end (especially Scamp!) and Lady's snarl and bark.

I much prefered the 2nd one, SOOOO CUTE!!!! The storyline was simple and adorable, the animation...let's just say, since The Lion King, the most beautiful and sparkly animation in an animated film! The songs were great fun and very easy to learn, my faves bieng Scamp's freedom song and Scamp and Angel's Love Song. Every young child I watch it with squels at how cute Scamp is, Angel bieng their second favourite. I also find this film better aimed towards teenagers, like how Scamp feels about his family and feeling like the "odd one out", we all do! later in the film, Scamp and Angel realise they are more than just "friends" and share a sweet romantic song which includes all the feelings they get when they become boyfriend and girlfriend. that's my fave thing about the film!

Overall, I'd rate the 1st film 2 stars and the 2nd 5 stars.

I think the songs were beautiful in the 1st one, and the movie DOES make sense, if you know about soap operas. As for the animation, it was great! It's quite realistic in some parts, and the dogs...they have the build and features of their breed! Oh, and I don't know what you mean by disappearing and changing colors...if you look at the DVD, the colors are SOLID and NOTHING disappears.

well. that's how i saw it. I found it ridiculous how Lady and Tramp spent about half a day together and by night they fell in love?!? It usually takes weeks!

Well i have to say th 1st one dosn't make SENCE! but it still good!
The 2nd one is much better and the songs r soooo good !

I agree with you 100% Frosty!

I'd tell you the title of my review, but it would offend you.

Fine. It's called On second thought, it sucks....
BUT, I gave it a 2 star! It was once a 4 and 1/2 stars! The thing is, after watching the second thought RIGHT AFTER the first one, I didn't love it anymore.