Animation Source Forums

According to the first movie. Charlies life present, past and future was written in the book that Anabelle had in Heaven at the time. Now according to that theory, How exactly does 2 come in to being then? If this was the case doesn't that mean that this was a plot in Heaven that had already been concocted as a test for Charlie and Itchy as they were meant to be sent down from Heaven? That makes little sense.. since ..that put the entire Heaven over in jeopardy if Charlie did in fact fail that test. It's something to think about how it ties together. However he was suppose to put his paw in the book as a signature.. in 1 he didn't and they never showed he did. So what do you guys think about it?

actually i think that in the first movie charlie proved he was able to break the rules/chains of fate and create his own destiny which is something that the big guy was hoping to find in a creature of his creation, and becuase of charlie's actions i think they just tossed the book and let the world go its own way instead of trying to control its every action. thus they had no way of knowing how the whole thing would turn out but anabelle odviously had faith in charlie if she actually granted him the mission either that or she was so smitten with him she couldnt say no

Agreed very much

You did it! You found the biggest plothole in the franchise!

Fair play, this issue is present in the first film too, and almost every curmudgeonly critic has pointed it out. If Heaven knows everything that's gonna happen, why didn't they know the conman was gonna con his way outta death? Checkmate, Dog Christians