Animation Source Forums

I don't know, who's your best or worst or favorite villain in the entire ADGTH universe?

I might have missed one,but I put the main ones I saw anyway.

Maybe I should say who is the best villain, who's the worst,and who's your favorite. Kinda confusing. Sorry.

Well It varies really. The Best Villan I bet Was Carface.. but that was in ADGTH 1 Carface was the WORST in 2, the series and 3. Belladonna was the best in The series in 3. though..the song "I Always.. get emotional at Christmas time.." kinda.. wrecked it..

Carface but only in the first movie. Out of all of the movies I thought the original Carface character was the best he was truely evil. And I thought Vic Tayback's voice was perfect. His menacing voice made Carface the top villain throughout everything. I thought he was terrible in the second movie the made him more like a puppet listening to whatever Red told him he was playing Killer's roll in the second movie. But I was glad to see he got his a little bit of his evilness back in the tv series even though he was listening to Belladonna he was told exactly what to do she was saying get this done and I don't care how just do it!

Nothing can ever replace the sheer evil and vileness of Carface in the first movie. In the series and the second movie, he's just totally whipped by Belladonna and Red and loses his edge.

What, he can run down Charlie with a car and have no problems but he can't talk back to two even less developed villains than himself? That's kinda odd.

i think that carface is the best villan
but only when he was in the first movie after that he kinda lost his spark
i can't really remember Red was he the cat in the second movie?

Yup.

Carface = Best in ADGTH 1. After that, meh.

I think Carface was the best villan in the first ADGTH..But after that he became a coward. I mean, what kind of dog serves a cat?

No real dog, I'll say.

I agree with both of yous 110%, you hit the nail on the head, seriously no dog would take orders from a pittiful cat, blaugh.

I chose Red. I simply love his design, as a cat demon i mean.

Has anyone noticed that in the first movie Carface's last name was Malone, then in the second movie his last name was Carumbus?

Carface, of course!

I chose Red. Red just rocked in that movie....the dog villans oddly didn't have much appeal to me. Usually its the dogs but in this movie I like Red the most.

Couldn't agree more. He was a horrible character, using children to is cruel advantage and plotting to kill his former partner. I mean, he used to almost frighten me when I was a kid. He was just awesome. I loved him.

But in ADGTH2... he was totally ruined, as was everyone else. But I think he got it the worst, he was a disgrace and a coward. That's not the evil vicious criminal demon we knew and loved in the original classic. Don't get me started on Charlie x3

Red annoyed me. His old dog disguise was cool, but he was mostly useless and annoying. meh.

Carface, no doubt about it. Well, only in ADGTH. In ADGTH 2, An All Dogs Christmas Carol, and the series, Carface is bland, I don't care for him much. He's a worse sidekick than Killer: at least Killer had some humor and actually tried to be evil!

But after ADGTH, everything seemed to get less appealing to me. The sequel and everything after, kinda cheesy. Really, a guy who tried to kill Charlie, not takes away bones from little orphaned doggies on Christmas? Blah.