Animation Source Forums

Who's your favorite voice for Charlie?

I can't decide,let the people vote...if there's not already a topic for this.

Not that I've seen... good idea though.
Being both a Burt Reynolds AND Charlie Sheen fan, it's hard to decide.
...probably Reynolds since I like the original movie most... >.>

I personally think Burt Reynolds was the best Charlie simply because his personality fit Charlie's personality the best, also his voice sounded the best as Charlie's. But I did think both Charlie Sheen and Steven Weber were really good Charlie's as well.

Mmm, interesting point. Though Charlie Sheen would be a similar personality if you watch Two and a Half Men. xD

I was only able to watch like... two (3? if you count the Christmas Special if he was in that) episodes of the series where Weber voiced.
I think I was to thrown off by (in my opinion) the horrid animation to really pay attention, but I didn't care for him...

Aughhh. I can't decide between Burt Reynolds and Charlie Sheen. Both have personalities that are pretty close to Charlie's, and they each have something positive to contribute. Reynolds has that grittier tone, which could reflect his con man background, but Sheen has that youthful feel to it as well.

I perfer Burt over Charlie Sheen's voice becuase it soo fits Charlie!I never liked the newer voices they keep givin' Charlie...

My votes for Reynolds. It just fits. The only thing I was bothered by really was Charlie's howl in the first movie... Sounded to girly in my opinion. But the complete voice of Charlie is a huge plus that sorta overlooks that.

Burt Reynolds brought more soul to the character IMO.

I think Charlie Sheen is the best voice for Charlie..For some reason, I don't like Burt Reynold's voice at all. Charlie Sheen makes Charlie sound younger, but not too much younger. In my oppinion..Charlie sounded like an old man in the first ADGTH.

Burt Reynolds all the way. His voice is hot. And the original ftw.

Buuut, I recently discovered Charlie Sheen plays as the character Charlie in Two and a Half Men - a show which I've recently gotten really into. So, that adds him brownie points xD He has a hot voice too, and he's awesome in the show. And he sounds cool as Charlie, except when he's yelling... he sounds weird then.

^ Hehehe, I've watched Two and a Half Men since it first aired [and seen and loved him in other things]. When I found out that he voiced Charlie in ADGTH 2, it took me by surprise, but in a good way. 8]
Anyone else find it humorously coincidental how he seems to keep playing 'Charlie's? xD

LOL I do xD

I completely agree with everything you say, Scout. I also liked Charlie Sheen as Charlie's voice more than B.Reynolds...Maybe just because I'm used to those "younger" voices...

I'm swinging out of left field here, I liked Steven Weber's voice over work the best.
He had such a rascally and lively voice, I thought it was a great fit for Charlie's character.

It probably doesn't help that I essentially watched the franchise backwards, started with the series and then watched the other two. I was used to Weber for a good 3 seasons worth of voice work, that his voice, to me, essentially WAS Charlie's.

Burt Reynolds did a bang up job as well, it sounded like he had an awful lot of fun doing it too.

I think that Sheen sounded a bit flat in the second film. Not bad, but not great. Would have been cool to see him do his own singing.