Animation Source Forums

Dear All.

Maybe a rating system for fan stuff, especially fanfics and fanpics could be good.
like a rating from one to 10 i.e.1(awful)-10 (excellent).
If this could be added to each fan fic or fanpic it woud be wonderful.

Sheba

yup looks like another great idea

Forget it.
It has been suggested last year about it, everyone said it's awful cause the small rated people might get pretty offended by having small ratings. And you know everyone wants to get appreciated even if they add hard work or not.
I guess steet said that it's not a pretty ideea :\

And I will have to say it again like then.
Hmm here viewtopic.php?t=4769

I guess the favourites is enough.. as rating, isn't it?

Er, there's already a topic like this as Deni said and it was decided that it wa'nt a very good idea back then and I don't see any reason why that would've changed now so...

Locked.

In fact, I thought of making something like this at the very start of the site...But removed it almost immediately, for the reasons that have already been quoted. (especially the fact that people could "cheat")
I think the favorites system is much more reliable though, because this is something that is "positive" (someone can't harm anyone by giving bad marks) and it's much more difficult to cheat.