[3] Rate that Avatar!

NattiKay · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 6:16 pm

10/10

Nicely made! ;)

Alicane · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 6:37 pm

Roi Doberwolf wrote:

9/10 - I like the uniqueness of the shape and I don't see anything wrong with the border. I think it rather fitting actually since Snoopy's white. But the red splotches throw me a bit. Snoopy and blood spatter what.

Thank :3 and i see what you mean with the blood and all. It's supposed to be about the part in WHAT A NIGHTMARE, CHARLIE BROWN when Snoopy and a Big Sled Dog fight. I guess most people didn't see the special

RoaKall · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 7:22 pm

Snoopy. angain. really? 4/10 It's gottn anoying

NattiKay · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 7:35 pm

RoaKall, please don't rate by personal preference. This is a topic meant for graphic advice and rating based on how well an icon is made, not by its content.

For your icon: 9/10

The only thing I see wrong with it is that its way too long horizontally.

For Alkan:

8/10

While I don't mind a rectangular shape, I feel that this one is a little too long for the image. Also, though I think the white boarder adds a nice effect, I also think that its strict rectangular-ness looks a bit odd with the more irregular shape of the gray section...but perhaps that's just me--as mentioned, it dose give good color contrast. Also, like Roi said, I think that the red splatters are a bit out-of-place, especially with no other reds to back them up. Other than the red, though, I like the color scheme, and the picture is good quality. :)

Alicane · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 8:31 pm

Nattikat8 wrote:

RoaKall, please don't rate by personal preference. This is a topic meant for graphic advice and rating based on how well an icon is made, not by its content.

For your icon: 9/10

The only thing I see wrong with it is that its way too long horizontally.

For Alkan:

8/10

While I don't mind a rectangular shape, I feel that this one is a little too long for the image. Also, though I think the white boarder adds a nice effect, I also think that its strict rectangular-ness looks a bit odd with the more irregular shape of the gray section...but perhaps that's just me--as mentioned, it dose give good color contrast. Also, like Roi said, I think that the red splatters are a bit out-of-place, especially with no other reds to back them up. Other than the red, though, I like the color scheme, and the picture is good quality.

Thank you for backing me up and the great review.

for you i don't see anything wrong 10/10 i think it's safe to say that your avatar is flawless. Great Color, creative and fun! Also very original

Roi Doberwolf · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 11:04 pm

Alkan wrote:

Roi Doberwolf wrote:

9/10 - I like the uniqueness of the shape and I don't see anything wrong with the border. I think it rather fitting actually since Snoopy's white. But the red splotches throw me a bit. Snoopy and blood spatter what.

Thank :3 and i see what you mean with the blood and all. It's supposed to be about the part in WHAT A NIGHTMARE, CHARLIE BROWN when Snoopy and a Big Sled Dog fight. I guess most people didn't see the special

Lawl, a'right. That makes more sense now. But still... can't imagine blood in a Snoopy cartoon. 9.9/10

Alicane · **Posted:** Sat May 12, 2012 11:49 pm

Roi Doberwolf wrote:

Alkan wrote:

Roi Doberwolf wrote:

9/10 - I like the uniqueness of the shape and I don't see anything wrong with the border. I think it rather fitting actually since Snoopy's white. But the red splotches throw me a bit. Snoopy and blood spatter what.

Thank :3 and i see what you mean with the blood and all. It's supposed to be about the part in WHAT A NIGHTMARE, CHARLIE BROWN when Snoopy and a Big Sled Dog fight. I guess most people didn't see the special

Lawl, a'right. That makes more sense now. But still... can't imagine blood in a Snoopy cartoon. 9.9/10

Yeah, I see what you mean. HAHAHAHAHAHAis

You... I don't exactly know who that is in the Avatar (Unless i'm not mistaken and it's Bruce Banner) but i see nothing wrong with it either. 10/10.

BTW: Thank you soooooo much for the sig!

RoaKall · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 5:20 pm

7/1O there should never be blood in CB cartoons

Alicane · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 6:05 pm

6.5/10 yeah, It needs to be cropped....

CrashKeys · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 6:08 pm

9/10
It's fine, but I would either brighten up the image or darken the blood. The brightness of the blood makes it look weird.

Alicane · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 6:09 pm

I think you're right..

10/10 like i said before. It's awesome!

NattiKay · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 6:31 pm

8/10, for reasons previously stated.

RoaKall wrote:

7/1O there should never be blood in CB cartoons

Again--PLEASE rate by graphic quality and not by your personal opinions.

Roi Doberwolf · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 8:32 pm

10/10! It's gorgeous! I love the effects and border! Fantastic avie! :3

-

Alkan wrote:

You... I don't exactly know who that is in the Avatar (Unless i'm not mistaken and it's Bruce Banner) but i see nothing wrong with it either. 10/10.

BTW: Thank you soooooo much for the sig!

Thanks! And yep! ...well kinda. It is of Mark Ruffalo who plays Banner. xD

Lawl, you're welcome again.

Alicane · **Posted:** Sun May 13, 2012 9:26 pm

Roi Doberwolf wrote:

10/10! It's gorgeous! I love the effects and border! Fantastic avie! :3

-

Alkan wrote:

You... I don't exactly know who that is in the Avatar (Unless i'm not mistaken and it's Bruce Banner) but i see nothing wrong with it either. 10/10.

BTW: Thank you soooooo much for the sig!

Thanks! And yep! ...well kinda. It is of Mark Ruffalo who plays Banner. xD

Lawl, you're welcome again.

10/10 for reasons previously stated and YEAH, I knew it was him!

MokiHunter · **Posted:** Mon May 14, 2012 5:31 am

9/10 Looks pretty good, though the shape of it seems off to me somehow...

Animation Source Forums

[3] Rate that Avatar!