Wonderful comparison and analysis, Jersey ^.^ I remember reading this book years ago, in middle school, and I remember thinking about how different it was in comparison to the movie. It always bothered me a little on the inside, even though I liked both of them. I must say, the larger affinity that I have is to the book; the story is just so much better! But I did like the way that the Shrew, Mr. Ages, and Jeremy were more humorous in the movie. As far as Justin's apparent death went - I've never personally thought he died. I don't have any evidence that would point to the contrary, but I find it hard that such young, strong rat like him wouldn't have managed to get away, even with the people from NIMH there. *shrug* But, that also could be because he was my favorite character

Thanks for putting so much effort into this topic! It was great to be able to stroll down memory lane and remember such a wonderful book again.