Animation Source Forums

10/10
Simple yet so pretty to look at < 33

9/10

The only thing I have against it is that the image on the right looks a little too faded/saturated compared to the rest of the sig. Other than that, looks great! 8D

10/10
Nice image and lovely quote.



Rotating banners. Specify which one do you rate.

Hiedvolk. 9/10 cuz I don't really like how it overlaps over their faces with the one picture...

9/10 I love the idea and it's nicely carried out, though I can't read the words in yellow D:

9,5/10
Nice drawing(but too red scars! xD).


Rotating banners. Specify which one do you rate.

Er, it's a grey one with a man in a hat and a long white beard. Not sure what the name of it is, lol.
Anyway, 9/10. I like how it all comes together, though I don't know what the text says because it's a bit small and hard to read. (I know it's also in a different language)

7/10
Background seems a bit overcrowded. Needs a better composition. And that Riki image has kinda bad quality. I like that Tokimune was made grey though xD


Rotating banners. Specify which one do you rate.

It has what looks like a wizard and a crow, along with some verses in a foreign language.

9.5/10

The color scheme and image blending is absolutely gorgeous, especially the clarity of what I assume to be the focal point on the left there; however, the text seems to kind of get sucked in to the image, not quite standing out and not quite blending in, which makes it look a little off to me.

9.5/10
I like the image and quote, but I can't tell if they're supposed to go together or not (it seems like they are). And the link to your character tutorial seems out of place. All in all, though, it's really good.

No graphic to rate! D:

But an 8/10 for the poem. It has a sweet message, but reading through it, I'm having a hard time picking out a meter. I know poems don't have to have meter, but in my humble opinion, they sound better and...well, more poetic when they do. XD


As for your comments on mine, no, the image and the quote don't go together; that's just a personal favorite quote of mine and I keep it in my signature whatever the graphic is.

Putting the link to my character guide is simply a way to spread the word...y'know, like "advertising" it, in a way. I don't find it any more out-of-place than when people put links to their art or image galleries in their sigs. -shrug-

Same as before lol

I wrote the poem based on the melody of a song I like, so you'd need to hear the song to understand the rhythm I had in mind.
Hidden text : click to show

8/10 It seems like a good poem to me, but the syllables could use some work. No image - the poem might look a lot nicer as an image (IMO), but other than that it's pretty good. C:

That's Odin and lyrics from Faroese ballad - "Regin Smidur".

7/10
For reasons stated before.

10/10
For the quote.




Rotating banners. Specify which one do you rate.

Mjolnir one. 9.5/10 I think it looks excellent, though the image to the middle left seems kind of... off. I don't know how to explain it.