[3] Rate that Avatar!

NattiKay · **Posted:** Fri Feb 08, 2013 1:03 pm

10/10

Troll Berserker wrote:

8/10
kinda small, and meh... I'm not a big fan of manga style anymore xD But nicely done.

Fluffykitty333 wrote:

not bad, but im not a fan of that style of drawing. 7/0

Please rate by graphic quality and not preference of style. :3 Thank you.

CrashKeys · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 9:56 am

9/10

The color is still light for me in the icon; the first few words are hard to read/

Roiffalo · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 2:53 pm

10/10 - excellent pixel (I think) art, I see nothing wrong with it. 8]

NattiKay wrote:

Please rate by graphic quality and not preference of style. :3 Thank you.

Thank YOU.

Troll Berserker wrote:

8/10
kinda small, and meh... I'm not a big fan of manga style anymore xD But nicely done.

And to note, I really don't see how being "small" is even worth a mention. It's 110*110, it's not THAT small. 50*50 is "small". Just my two cents. Thank you regardless.

Fluffykitty333 · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 3:57 pm

I like it. Great pixels, and the boarder is great too. 9.5/10

MokiHunter · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 5:08 pm

6/10 Sorry, but it's terrible quality...

Fluffykitty333 · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 7:39 pm

Moki Hunter wrote:

6/10 Sorry, but it's terrible quality...

I don't see how that's terrible quality...

10/10. I love the style.

NattiKay · **Posted:** Sat Feb 09, 2013 9:51 pm

5/10

The image quality is fuzzy and it's hard to decipher where the lines are. The two thick boarders around the edges are also fuzzy and seem to be rather random; they fit neither with each other nor with the image of Toothless. Lastly, while I'm all for simplicity, the plain white background is simply unappealing and, again, doesn't match with the rest of the image.

Troll Berserker · **Posted:** Sun Feb 10, 2013 5:17 am

8/10
Feels like it's missing something, like a crop of a bigger image.

NattiKay wrote:

Please rate by graphic quality and not preference of style. :3 Thank you.

Graphic is about how it's done and what's on it. And style is a part of art too so as long as I think Saiyuki is a great manga, I don't think artist's tyle is really good.

MokiHunter · **Posted:** Sun Feb 10, 2013 4:40 pm

9/10 I think it's a good drawing and well-made graphic, but the way it's cropped both on the top and left sides is bothering me a bit...

NattiKay · **Posted:** Sun Feb 10, 2013 7:20 pm

10/10

Roiffalo · **Posted:** Sun Feb 10, 2013 8:55 pm

It's a cute avie with great colors, simple border, and I like the words. But they're a TAD hard to read. - 9.5/10
Though I have nothing against smaller avies myself, making it a bit bigger may make it easier to read the text.

Troll Berserker wrote:

Graphic is about how it's done and what's on it. And style is a part of art too so as long as I think Saiyuki is a great manga, I don't think artist's tyle is really good.

Though I don't agree I s'pose we all have our preferences with how we rate. AND WAIT WHAT YOU LIKE SAIYUKI. I think I love you.

Troll Berserker · **Posted:** Mon Feb 11, 2013 1:22 pm

10/10
Really nice drawing and well-done image. I rarely like non-black borders but this one fits very well.

Lawl, it's still one of my faves. Gojyo is awesome xD

Roiffalo · **Posted:** Mon Feb 11, 2013 4:15 pm

Thanks! I'm rather proud of the whole pic myself.
Yours- 10/10, I love the art, and the shape is different, which I like.

Hehe, same, it was a fav before and now I've randomly returned to obsessing over it. Hakkai's obviously mine, but he and Gojyo are one of my favorite brotps. 8)

MokiHunter · **Posted:** Tue Feb 12, 2013 11:37 am

10/10 the art is awesome as always Roi, and the border fits nicely!

CrashKeys · **Posted:** Thu Feb 14, 2013 2:35 pm

10/10
It's very nice! I don't see much wrong. The only thing would be the lines with the dark color, but that's a big preference thing

Animation Source Forums

[3] Rate that Avatar!